Hainan Airlines to serve Beijing-Chicago with Boeing 787 in Apr-2013
While both American Airlines and United Airlines serve the Beijing-Chicago market, American Airlines is disadvantaged as it has unideal slots at constrained Beijing, which limits connections.
As a result, its performance has lagged that of United and its own performance between Chicago and Shanghai, where it has more practical slots. American has partially compensated by carrying more cargo, from which Hainan also stands to benefit.
American and United each currently have daily 777-200 service, although United has in the past also used 747-400s.
The carrier expects to operate four weekly services on Beijing-Chicago through Mar-2014, but this could be accelerated. Hainan increased Beijing-Seattle from four weekly to daily in Jun-2012, four years after the route’s 2008 launch, but China-US traffic flows are increasing and Chicago is a larger market than Seattle. Hainan also now has American Airlines as a partner. Hainan expects to make a modest operation profit of RMB6 million (USD952,000) in its first year of operation, assuming four weekly flights.
The lack of a Chinese carrier in Chicago allowed Hainan to receive in Jun-2011 permission from Beijing to operate the route as early as Sep-2011. Not all of Hainan’s previous route requests have been approved by Beijing. China Eastern and China Southern have likely stayed out of Chicago due to the lack of a partner (both are in SkyTeam, which has a weak presence in Chicago) while Air China may have wanted to avoid competition with United, with whom it has a closer relationship than American and Hainan do.
American Airlines likely to codeshare on Hainan’s Beijing-Chicago service
In another market pairing without anti-trust immunity, American may see a partner’s entry as negative given greater competition. But given American’s disadvantage in Beijing, Hainan’s entry may help boost American’s service. American commenced Chicago-Beijing services in 2010, by which time Beijing had become severely slot-constrained, with only late night and early morning slots available. United in comparison started its service earlier and was able to attain favourable afternoon slots, facilitating connections. United, based on its current schedule, typically arrives in Beijing at 14:40 and departs at 16:10.
American’s schedule sees it arrive in Beijing between 21:30 and 23:30 and then depart between 06:55 and 09:50, although five of its daily services depart before 08:00, eliminating opportunities for inward connections from elsewhere in China. Dometic connections on the outbound sector are also virtually impossible because the Chinese Government does not allow carriers to operate red-eye flights in the domestic market.
Hainan, however, is in a far more favorable position given its already large access to slots at Beijing. Hainan has the fourth largest amount of movements, and thus current active slots, at Beijing.
The initially low number of seats Hainan will offer, combined with the fact it is likely to market more to the Chinese market than the US market, should see little lasting pressure on yields aside from typical launch fares.
The lack of convenient slots at Beijing is outside of American Airlines’ control, but it has affected the carrier’s performance on the Beijing-Chicago route. In American’s first 20 months on the route, it has had a lower load factor than United Airlines in all but one month when it recorded a load factor less than 1ppt higher. Its average load factor in 2011 was 73% compared to 87% at United. Only load factor information through Dec-2011 is available while there is no yield information.
American’s load factors were initially as high as they were at the start of services in May-2010 because American had sold the service with "placeholder" afternoon arrival and departure slots at Beijing, believing it would be able to attain those slots. Instead American received late night and early morning slots, and as this situation became evident – and public – load factors dipped. In a rare occurrence, American’s Beijing-Chicago load factor has, through the end of 2011, yet to surpass the first two months of operations. Typically launch months see the lowest load factors.
Beijing-Chicago passenger load factors: 2010 to 2011
Shanghai-Chicago passenger load factors: 2010 to 2011
Cargo from Asia generally has higher value than cargo arriving into Asia. Chicago-Beijing cargo in 2011 accounted for 12% of American’s available payload compared to 4% for United. Beijing-Chicago cargo accounted for 28% of American’s payload and 19% for United. (United has higher cargo uplift on its Chinese services to Los Angeles and San Francisco, which require less fuel.)
Note: Hainan reported zero cargo uplift in Jan-2009
American Airlines frustrated with Beijing slot situation
But the lack of ideally timed slots has been a major frustration of American Airlines. The carrier cancelled its first planned Chicago-Beijing launch in Apr-2010 mere hours before the flight was due to depart. Beijing had initially given American a 02:20 arrival slot and 04:20 departure slot, but American believed it could secure more favorable slots and so scheduled its service with "placeholder" slots entailing a 13:55 Beijing arrival and 16:55 departure, according to local reports at the time. The original Beijing slots would have entailed departing Chicago at midnight and arriving back at 04:00.
American had been negotiating with authorities up until 05:00 on the day of the planned inaugural. The midnight hours slots "are inconsistent with local market demand and would complicate flight connections for passengers in Beijing and Chicago," a spokesman said at the time.
American said it expected to receive "preferential treatment" as a new entrant carrier in line with "established International Air Transport Association and industry guidelines and procedures". But as the situation at other airlines has shown, Beijing’s congestion issue is not negotiable, at least until a new airport opens later this decade. The service was postponed again on 04-May-2010 before finally launching on 25-May-2010 when American received evening landing slots and morning departure slots.
Hainan’s Chicago service will balance US-China flows
This site contains materials from other clearly stated media sources for the purpose of discussion stimulation and content enrichment among our members only.
whatsonsanya.com does not necessarily endorse their views or the accuracy of their content. For copyright infringement issues please contact email@example.com
Previous news: Wuzhizhou Island off Haitang Bay, Sanya’s best known secret
Next news: Travel to Sanya to escape northern freeze